Quote:I think he doesn't update sample size number in table when updated haplo values.
Maybe, but I would expect better precision from the author. You should ask him to send us updated table with data as of 2023.
Quote:No need to be so strict.
I disagree. Excellent precision is expected especially from a German author - instead there is a lack of precision and strictness...
Maybe he just invented these percentage values taking them out of his ass.
We don't know because of his lack of strictness.Quote:Still your R1a value is too big for ethnic Germans too.
And his 21% is too low for Lower Silesia which can be seen even when comparing it to neighbouring regions (north and west).
We would expect a continuum between Upper Silesia and Saxony/Brandenburg, with Lower Silesia having intermediate values. Instead we have Lower Silesia with lower value of R1a than all neighbouring regions including these to the west and to the north - which is weird and improbable.