11-13-2023, 03:25 PM
Guys, this thread is going in all directions, and I think the time has come for a necessary clarification.
The subject of this thread is very explicitly the proto-Germanic language.
1) If he applies to himself the rule that he claims to impose on others ("No Source -> No Theory"), Rodoorn has nothing to say on this subject, and short of a miracle this is not likely to change.
2) As soon as there are "sources" (that is to say if I correctly understood written sources), it means that we very significantly post-date the time window within from which a question relating to proto-Germanic may arise. This is particularly true for all groups described as "Germans" by Roman sources. These subjects, although quite fascinating, are out of place here.
On the previous forum Rodoorn had opened a thread dedicated to the questions mentioned in 2). I urge him to revive this thread on our new GenArchivist.
The subject of this thread is very explicitly the proto-Germanic language.
1) If he applies to himself the rule that he claims to impose on others ("No Source -> No Theory"), Rodoorn has nothing to say on this subject, and short of a miracle this is not likely to change.
2) As soon as there are "sources" (that is to say if I correctly understood written sources), it means that we very significantly post-date the time window within from which a question relating to proto-Germanic may arise. This is particularly true for all groups described as "Germans" by Roman sources. These subjects, although quite fascinating, are out of place here.
On the previous forum Rodoorn had opened a thread dedicated to the questions mentioned in 2). I urge him to revive this thread on our new GenArchivist.
MyHeritage:
North and West European 55.8%
English 28.5%
Baltic 11.5%
Finnish 4.2%
GENETIC GROUPS Scotland (Aberdeen and Aberdeenshire)
Papertrail (4 generations): Normandy, Orkney, Bergum, Emden, Oulu
North and West European 55.8%
English 28.5%
Baltic 11.5%
Finnish 4.2%
GENETIC GROUPS Scotland (Aberdeen and Aberdeenshire)
Papertrail (4 generations): Normandy, Orkney, Bergum, Emden, Oulu